Here is the comparison results for the chosen plugins

Plugin nameSocial Media Share Buttons & Social Sharing IconsSocial Media Share Buttons | MashShare
Version2.7.53.8.1
AuthorUltimatelySocialRené Hermenau
Tested upto (WordPress Version)6.05.9.3
Required PHP Version5.6
Rating
5 star
4813
4 star
224
3 star
35
2 star
34
1 star
90

Total reviews: 5196(98%)

5 star
901
4 star
60
3 star
17
2 star
5
1 star
34

Total reviews: 1017(96%)

Resolved issues20 out of 23
86.96%
2 out of 5
40.00%
Active installs

200000+

30000+

Screenshots
DownloadDownloadDownload