Here is the comparison results for the chosen plugins

Plugin nameSocial Media Share Buttons & Social Sharing IconsSocial Media Share Buttons | MashShare
Version2.7.53.8.1
AuthorUltimatelySocialRené Hermenau
Tested upto (WordPress Version)6.05.9.3
Required PHP Version5.6
Rating
5 star
4813
4 star
224
3 star
35
2 star
34
1 star
90

Total reviews: 5196(98%)

5 star
901
4 star
60
3 star
17
2 star
5
1 star
34

Total reviews: 1017(96%)

Resolved issues20 out of 23
86.96%
2 out of 5
40.00%
Active installs

200000+

30000+

Screenshots
<p>After installing the plugin, you'll see this overview. You'll be taken through the easy-to-understand steps to configure your plugin</p><p>As a first step you select which share icons you want to display on your website</p><p>Then you'll define what the share icons should do (they can perform several actions, e.g. lead users to your facebook page, or allow them to share your content on their facebook page)</p><p>You can pick from a wide range of share icon designs</p><p>Here you can animate your social share icons (automatic shuffling, mouse-over effects etc.), to make visitors of your site aware that they can share, follow & like your site</p><p>You can choose to display counts next to your social share icons (e.g. number of Twitter-followers)</p><p>There are many more options to choose from</p><p>You can also add social share icons at the end of every post</p><p>...or even display a pop-up (designed to your liking) which asks users to like & share your site</p>
Subscribe form with Social Media Facebook share button and mail subscribeDefault share buttons with separate available responsive Add-OnSortable Total Share DashboardDefault Share buttons with separate available responsive Add-OnResponsive Design + Social-Networks (separate Add-Ons)Default Share buttons + Subscribe Button opened (included)Social Media Settings on the post edit screenSticky Sharebar Add-On on a desktop deviceCircle style (included)Custom Social Sharing descriptions with free MashShare Open Graph Add-OnExtend MashShare with great Add-Ons
DownloadDownloadDownload
Another Comparison

Related Comparisons by WPfloor Users

Social Media Share Buttons & Social Sharing Icons VS Social Media Share Buttons | MashShare