Here is the comparison results for the chosen plugins

Plugin nameAll-In-One Security (AIOS) – Security and FirewallWordfence Security – Firewall, Malware Scan, and Login Security
Version5.3.07.11.5
AuthorAll In One WP Security & Firewall TeamWordfence
Tested upto (WordPress Version)6.5.26.5.2
Required PHP Version5.65.5
Rating
5 star
1415
4 star
51
3 star
19
2 star
14
1 star
68

Total reviews: 1567(94%)

5 star
3715
4 star
91
3 star
60
2 star
43
1 star
238

Total reviews: 4147(94%)

Resolved issues52 out of 64
81.25%
184 out of 265
69.43%
Active installs

1000000+

5000000+

Screenshots
Features list.
The dashboard gives you an overview of your site's security including notifications, attack statistics and Wordfence feature status.The firewall protects your site from common types of attacks and known security vulnerabilities.The Wordfence Security Scanner lets you know if your site has been compromised and alerts you to other security issues that need to be addressed.Wordfence is highly configurable, with a deep set of options available for each feature. High level scan options are shown above.Brute Force Protection features protect you from password guessing attacks.Block attackers by IP, Country, IP range, Hostname, Browser or Referrer.The Wordfence Live Traffic view shows you real-time activity on your site including bot traffic and exploit attempts.Take login security to the next level with Two-Factor Authentication.Logging in is easy with Wordfence 2FA.
DownloadDownloadDownload
Another Comparison

Related Comparisons by WPfloor Users

All-In-One Security (AIOS) – Security and Firewall VS Wordfence Security – Firewall, Malware Scan, and Login Security
Jetpack – WP Security, Backup, Speed, & Growth VS Wordfence Security – Firewall & Malware Scan
BulletProof Security VS Wordfence Security – Firewall & Malware Scan
Jetpack – WP Security, Backup, Speed, & Growth VS Wordfence Security – Firewall, Malware Scan, and Login Security
BulletProof Security VS Wordfence Security – Firewall, Malware Scan, and Login Security