Here is the comparison results for the chosen plugins

Plugin nameReally Simple SSLShield Security – Scanners, Security Hardening, Brute Force Protection & Firewall
Version5.2.213.0.6
AuthorReally Simple PluginsShield Security
Tested upto (WordPress Version)5.8.35.9
Required PHP Version5.67.0
Rating
5 star
7425
4 star
70
3 star
11
2 star
9
1 star
41

Total reviews: 7556(100%)

5 star
918
4 star
24
3 star
11
2 star
8
1 star
18

Total reviews: 979(98%)

Resolved issues42 out of 52
80.77%
6 out of 8
75.00%
Active installs

5000000+

60000+

Screenshots
DownloadDownloadDownload