Here is the comparison results for the chosen plugins

Plugin nameTrack Google Analytics 4, Facebook Pixel & Conversions API via Google Tag Manager for WooCommerceMonsterInsights – Google Analytics Dashboard for WordPress (Website Stats Made Easy)
Version6.9.08.22.0
AuthorConversiosMonsterInsights
Tested upto (WordPress Version)6.3.26.4.1
Required PHP Version7.2
Rating
5 star
169
4 star
4
3 star
5
2 star
3
1 star
22

Total reviews: 203(90%)

5 star
2324
4 star
83
3 star
39
2 star
45
1 star
239

Total reviews: 2730(90%)

Resolved issues2 out of 3
66.67%
19 out of 21
90.48%
Active installs

20000+

3000000+

Screenshots
This is the Dashboard screen which shows the status of the Google Tag Manager implementation and setup of the various pixels, the link status of the Google Merchant Center, TikTok catalog, and the latest 2 feeds, and report insights for the running campaigns and the last 30 days' data for GA4This is a screenshot of the Pixels and Analytics page where you can browse the configuration you have done so far for your Google Tag Manager account. You can click on any integration to add/update the settings.You can view all the pixels' configurations and browse to a specific pixel to add/update the account.This is a Google Tag Manager setting page where you can configure your Google Tag Manager container or use Conversion Global Container (default).All the 76+ pre built tags, triggers and variable in your GTM account.This is a Google Analytics setting page.This is a Google Ads settings page where you can configure Google Ads conversion tracking, enhanced conversion tracking & dynamic remarketing tags for ecommerce events.This is a Facebook configuration page where you can configure Facebook Pixel and Facebook Conversions API tracking.Actionable dashboard which displays the key metrics that help your ecommerce business scale faster. ecommerce conversion and checkout funnel reports that help you to visualize user journeys from the Home page to order confirmation. Product, Source/Medium and Campaign Performance Report where you can see all the respective performances.Google Analytics 4 dashboard 1 Once you connect Google Analytics 4 property from the plugin, your WooCommerce store's data will look like this in your Google Analytics 4 dashboard. The plugin captures all the data points related to ecommerce events.Google Analytics 4 dashboard 2 Once you connect Google Analytics 4 property from the plugin, your WooCommerce store's data will look like this in your Google Analytics 4 dashboard. The plugin captures all the data points related to ecommerce events.Google Analytics 4--> Monetization 1 Once you connect Google Analytics 4 property from the plugin, your WooCommerce store's data will look like this in your Google Analytics 4 under Monetization --> Overview. The plugin captures all the data points related to ecommerce events.Google Analytics 4--> Monetization 2 Once you connect Google Analytics 4 property from the plugin, your WooCommerce store's data will look like this in your Google Analytics 4 under Monetization --> Overview. The plugin captures all the data points related to ecommerce events.Google Analytics 4 Monetization --> ecommerce purchases Once you connect Google Analytics 4 property from the plugin, your WooCommerce store's data will look like this in your Google Analytics 4 under Monetization --> ecommerce purchases. The plugin captures all the data points related to ecommerce events.Product Feed --> Channel Configuration where you can link your Google Merchant Center Account and TikTok catalog to process Product Feed.This is the inner setting page for Google Merchant Center where you can SignIn using Google account and select Google Merchant Center Account to link along with doing Site verification and Domain claim.This is the inner setting page for TikTok catalog where you can Sign In using your Tiktok account, select TikTok Business Account and set TikTok catalogs country-wise.Product Feed --> Feed Management. This is where you can create and manage feeds.Product Feed --> Channel Configuration --> Attribute and Category mapping. This is where you can map your WooCommerce product attributes and categories to the Conversios product attributes and categories and save them.
The overview reportTop countries and referralsTop posts and pagesAuthentication with MonsterInsightsSettings pageFile download trackingeCommerce tracking - no configuration required (Pro feature)eCommerce report (Pro feature)Search console report (Pro feature)Custom dimensions tracking (Pro feature)Custom Dimensions report (Pro feature)
DownloadDownloadDownload
Another Comparison

Related Comparisons by WPfloor Users

Conversios.io – Google Analytics (GA4) and Google Shopping plugin for WooCommerce VS MonsterInsights – Google Analytics Dashboard for WordPress (Website Stats Made Easy)
Conversios.io – Google Analytics and Google Shopping plugin for WooCommerce VS MonsterInsights – Google Analytics Dashboard for WordPress (Website Stats Made Easy)
Actionable Google Analytics and Google Shopping plugin for WooCommerce VS MonsterInsights – Google Analytics Dashboard for WordPress (Website Stats Made Easy)
All-in-one Google Analytics, Pixels and Product Feed Manager for WooCommerce VS MonsterInsights – Google Analytics Dashboard for WordPress (Website Stats Made Easy)
MonsterInsights – Google Analytics Dashboard for WordPress (Website Stats Made Easy) VS Track Google Analytics 4, Facebook Pixel & Conversions API via Google Tag Manager for WooCommerce