Here is the comparison results for the chosen plugins

Plugin nameContact Form 7Forminator Forms – Contact Form, Payment Form & Custom Form Builder
Version6.1.51.52.2
AuthorRock Lobster Inc.WPMU DEV - Your All-in-One WordPress Platform
Tested upto (WordPress Version)6.9.46.9.4
Required PHP Version7.47.4
Rating
5 star
1462
4 star
151
3 star
77
2 star
68
1 star
404

Total reviews: 2162(80%)

5 star
1915
4 star
64
3 star
25
2 star
12
1 star
43

Total reviews: 2059(96%)

Resolved issues22 out of 68
32.35%
60 out of 67
89.55%
Active installs

10000000+

600000+

Screenshots
DownloadDownloadDownload