Here is the comparison results for the chosen plugins

Plugin nameAll in One SEO – Best WordPress SEO Plugin – Easily Improve SEO Rankings & Increase TrafficYoast SEO
Version4.2.219.1
AuthorAll in One SEO TeamTeam Yoast
Tested upto (WordPress Version)6.06.0
Required PHP Version5.45.6.20
Rating
5 star
1936
4 star
65
3 star
16
2 star
25
1 star
178

Total reviews: 2220(92%)

5 star
25803
4 star
620
3 star
182
2 star
127
1 star
748

Total reviews: 27480(96%)

Resolved issues67 out of 74
90.54%
335 out of 405
82.72%
Active installs

3000000+

5000000+

Screenshots
SEO Content Analyzer (Gutenberg)SEO Content Analyzer (Classic Editor)SEO Setup WizardSEO Site AnalysisWebmaster Tools ConnectSocial Media IntegrationsLocal SEOSitemapsSearch Appearance SettingsRobots.txt EditorRSS Content ControlHeadline AnalyzerRedirect ManagerLink Assistant
The Yoast SEO plugin general meta box. You'll see this on edit post pages, for posts, pages and custom post types.Example of the SEO analysis functionality.Example of the readability analysis functionality.Overview of site-wide SEO problems and possible improvements.Control over which features you want to use.Easily import SEO data from other SEO plugins like All In One SEO pack, HeadSpace2 SEO and wpSEO.de.
DownloadDownloadDownload
Another Comparison

Related Comparisons by WPfloor Users

All in One SEO – Best WordPress SEO Plugin – Easily Improve SEO Rankings & Increase Traffic VS Rank Math SEO – Best SEO Plugin For WordPress To Increase Your SEO Traffic VS Yoast SEO
All in One SEO – Best WordPress SEO Plugin – Easily Improve SEO Rankings & Increase Traffic VS Yoast SEO